Go to Content Go to Navigation Go to Navigation Go to Site Search Homepage

Earlier this week, Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor grabbed some headlines (and understandably caused some confusion) after she temporarily blocked implementation of the Affordable Care Act’s birth control benefit requirement as applied to religiously affiliated organizations.  To be clear: the dispute does not in any way involve whether or not churches and places of worship are exempt from covering birth control (they are).  Rather, the dispute is about other, religiously affiliated organizations, and how they can choose to “opt out” of the requirement.

When birth control with no copay became available under the Affordable Care Act’s preventive health benefit, the Obama administration made an accommodation for these religiously affiliated institutions and places of worship.  That accommodation still exists and these organizations object to having to sign a form by which they can opt out.  All Justice Sotomayor did was to temporarily suspend this requirement while awaiting the response from the Justice Department.  The Justice Department quickly responded to Sotomayor, filing a brief making clear that the organizations that filled the emergency challenge are not required to cover contraception for its employees.

Importantly, the ruling did not affect the 27 million women who have access to birth control with no out-of-pocket costs thanks to the Affordable Care Act.  Each and every day women are leading healthier lives because of the preventive care benefit, which includes access to birth control.  However, the discussion around birth control in 2014 is just beginning.  While these latest legal actions are making headlines, a bigger question lies on the horizon, and will be heard by the U.S. Supreme Court in the spring.

The Supreme Court will be faced with the question of whether for-profit companies should be able to deny women access to birth control based on their personal beliefs when they hear the cases brought by Hobby Lobby—a large craft store chain—and Conestoga Wood Specialties—a cabinet manufacturer.  Not only could these cases affect the millions of women who already have access to birth control with no copay under their insurance, but it could also create a slippery slope where any boss could deny a whole host of other medical procedures, such as vaccines, surgeries, blood transfusions, and mental health care, based on his own personal beliefs.

The choice to use birth control should be between a woman and her doctor, not between a woman and her employer.  Women don’t turn to their bosses for medical advice, they shouldn’t have to ask their boss whether they can get access to birth control or not. The Supreme Court will be faced with this question in their upcoming session, and we will keep you posted along the way.

Tags: Obamacare, Affordable Care Act, Supreme Court, SCOTUS, Birth Control Lawsuits, Justice Sotomayor, birth control

Is Abortion Still Legal in My State?

Learn about abortion access changes in your state.

Get the Facts

Demand court reform now!

To protect and advance our rights, we must reclaim our federal courts. 
Structural, systemic, and meaningful court reform is the only way to ensure that courts uphold the law and protect our rights.

Add your name

Planned Parenthood Action Fund Will NEVER Back Down

Know this: our right to abortion is not debatable. We will rebuild and reclaim the freedom that is ours.


Sign Up for Email

Sign Up

This website uses cookies

Planned Parenthood cares about your data privacy. We and our third-party vendors use cookies and other tools to collect, store, monitor, and analyze information about your interaction with our site to improve performance, analyze your use of our sites and assist in our marketing efforts. You may opt out of the use of these cookies and other tools at any time by visiting Cookie Settings. By clicking “Allow All Cookies” you consent to our collection and use of such data, and our Terms of Use. For more information, see our Privacy Notice.

Cookie Settings

Planned Parenthood cares about your data privacy. We and our third-party vendors, use cookies, pixels, and other tracking technologies to collect, store, monitor, and process certain information about you when you access and use our services, read our emails, or otherwise engage with us. The information collected might relate to you, your preferences, or your device. We use that information to make the site work, analyze performance and traffic on our website, to provide a more personalized web experience, and assist in our marketing efforts. We also share information with our social media, advertising, and analytics partners. You can change your default settings according to your preference. You cannot opt-out of our Necessary Cookies as they are deployed to ensure the proper functioning of our website (such as prompting the cookie banner and remembering your settings, to log into your account, to redirect you when you log out, etc.). For more information, please see our Privacy Notice.



We use online advertising to promote our mission and help constituents find our services. Marketing pixels help us measure the success of our campaigns.



We use qualitative data, including session replay, to learn about your user experience and improve our products and services.



We use web analytics to help us understand user engagement with our website, trends, and overall reach of our products.